#23 – Slaughterhouse Five Review – Kurt Vonnegut

Slaughterhouse Five Cover

Summary | Review | Buy
I should probably be clear about this from the very start: Kurt Vonnegut is one of my favorite writers of all time and Slaughterhouse Five is probably the best book he’s ever written in my humble opinion – and if that clouds my review in any way, well…so it goes. Blending equal amounts humor, history and absurdist fantasy, the book amounts to nothing less than a treatise on free will, the nature of the universe and the inevitability of human conflict. It is thought provoking, side-splittingly funny and eminently readable, while also being an unflinching look at one of the most horrific tragedies of the 20th century. Not many authors can juggle this many themes and topics together in one book (all while using a non-linear narrative), but Vonnegut is definitely one who can. Now that I think about it, Slaughterhouse-Five is probably the first book to get me interested in Science Fiction – and to make me realize that events in a novel don’t necessarily have to be realistic to make profound statements about the realities of the human condition.

Slaughterhouse-Five Summary: Slaughterhouse-Five (or The Children’s Crusade: A Duty Dance With Death) recounts various moments in the life of Billy Pilgrim, a reluctant soldier during World War II. As I mentioned before, the novel is told in a non-linear fashion, meaning that the narrative skips around to various moments in Billy’s life out of chronological order. Vonnegut describes him as being “unstuck in time,” uncertain as to which moment in his life he will be “re-living” next. During the course of the novel, we see Billy as a German prisoner being held in a slaughterhouse in the city of Dresden (during the Bombing of Dresden), as a captive of an alien race from the planet Tralfamadore who exhibit him as part of their zoo along with a porn actress, as a married man in post-war America, and even during his death. The totality of his experiences, along with a revelation by the Tralfamadorians about the 4 dimensional nature of the universe, eventually leads Billy to accept the predetermined nature of his own life (and that of a humanity that believes foolishly in free-will). While the book may be consider an “Anti-War” novel, it could just as easily be classified as an “Inevitability of War” book, as Billy’s reaction to some of the novels most disturbing revelations about death and the nature of mortality is the oft-repeated phrase…so it goes.

The pivotal event in the novel is the now-infamous firebombing of the city of Dresden by the British Royal Air Force in 1945. Vonnegut himself was actually a German prisoner of war during the bombing and was forced to help dispose of the bodies after the attack was over. The profound meaninglessness of the bombing in the overall scheme of the war along with the astronomically high number of civilian casualties had a profound affect on him, and the reality of that experience can be felt distinctly throughout the book. It is inevitable that Billy Pilgrim is often seen as an extension of Vonnegut himself, even though the voice of “Vonnegut” the narrator also makes brief appearances at various points in the novel. One of his other alter-egos, struggling Science Fiction writer Kilgore Trout, also makes a cameo, along with a few other characters that would become or had been characters in other of his novels, including Howard W. Campbell, Jr. and Eliot Rosewater.

Slaughterhouse-Five Review: While Slaughterhouse-Five is often accused of being “Fatalistic” and that Vonnegut seems resigned to the atrocities of man as pre-determined and inevitable (as well as being frequently censored due to its “obscene” content and irreverence when talking about issues that are often cloaked in solemnity and reverence), it is also one of the best examples of how post-modern novelists often try to examine the absurdity of our search for meaning and transcendence in the face of such blatant assaults on our notions of decency and human compassion. To me, Vonnegut isn’t telling us that war is a fact of life that we should just accept. Instead, he is showing us the ways in which we attempt to rationalize and normalize these experiences so as not to be overcome by their inherent meaninglessness. And the fact that he is able to do this while at the same time being a ruthlessly funny and compelling storyteller is a testament to his ability as a writer and social satirist. I can’t recommend this book highly enough, whether you are a fan of Science Fiction or not.

Buy Slaughterhouse-Five:

Paperback Movie Kindle
Written by
September 8, 2010

4 thoughts on “#23 – Slaughterhouse Five Review – Kurt Vonnegut”

  1. This is also one of my all time favorite books. In some sense I find Billy Pilgrim to be an unsympathetic main character, and usually for me that makes it hard to like a book, but I like this one nonetheless. It has that same kind of sense of being a passenger watching messed-up things as Catcher in the Rye, where Holden Caulfield is so upset by all the weirdness of the world. I passionately hate Catcher in the Rye, but I think that’s because Holden Caulfield is so proud of himself for recognizing that the world is messed up, and is so judgmental and supercilious to the people who are messed up in it.Billy Pilgrim, although he’s kind of unsympathetic in that he doesn’t ever DO much, doesn’t seem to want to judge or distance himself from all the fucked up things. They are what they are, and he knows he can’t necessarily change that.

  2. You’re right. I think a lot of Vonnegut’s characters seemed to be resigned to their fate in a messed up world, but for me I think that is endearing at some level. They are able to observe the absurdity of the universe without suffering from the delusional notion that they can do anything about it. While I personally enjoyed the Catcher in the Rye, I agree that Holden does come off as a bit of a self-congratulating pessimist. I guess when you’re younger, it really does seem like you’re the only one who gets it and that everyone else is square. When you get older you realize that the world is just as messed up, but that you’re not the only one that feels alone against the world.

  3. Slaughterhouse Five is an artistically written book, but a poor story. This novel does not belong in the Science Fiction genre. Despite it’s inclusion in many “Top Science Fiction Novels” list, the closest it gets to SF is when Billy has repeated hallucinations (as the result of a major brain trauma) about living in different time periods . The new hallucinations go on to also serve Billy as treatment for his
    post-traumatic stress disorder brought on by his time as a P.O.W. in WWII, and his up close and personal experience with the firebombing of Dresden, Germany. The novel is much more a social commentary on pre-destination and the meaningless of atrocities and violence in general. Move on if you are looking for good Sci-Fi.

Leave a Reply to Tom Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.